Disappointed
"Love the color of these jeans and petite length but very disappointed with sizing issues I ve encountered. This seems to be a common complaint in the reviews. Seems to be very poor quality control."
Overall rating: 4.5840707 / 5 from 113 reviews.
The Marilyn Straight Jeans in Petite by NYDJ are praised for their flattering fit, soft and sturdy fabric, and perfect length. Customers appreciate the high quality and great color, though opinions on size vary.
Review topics: ["color","fit","length","problem","size","fabric","look","jeans","quality","material","weight","pants","stretch","difference","style","nydj","waist","gap","name","pair","green","marilyn","change"].
"Love the color of these jeans and petite length but very disappointed with sizing issues I ve encountered. This seems to be a common complaint in the reviews. Seems to be very poor quality control."
"I really like these Marilyns in the color feather as we transition to fall. The petite length allows me to wear them with flats. They do seem to run a little smaller than my other Marilyns. Perhaps because they are petite."
"Previous NYDJ 0Petite Marilyn Straight jeans have been a perfect fit and length. Inexplicably, this pair, tagged 0 Petite, is nearly 3” too long. Fortunately, I have the skill and sewing machine to alter the jeans for the length I want/need."
"I’ve been buying this brand for quite a few years and I have never been disappointed"
"Great but I had to pay to have them hemmed. Your "petites" are just too long with a 30" inseam. You need to have a "Petite Short" 26" to 27" Inseam."
"Great pants. Great fit."
"I have narrow hips and slender thighs so Marilyn Straight is perfect for me. I do have to shorten them to a 28" inseam but that is not a problem for me as I have a sewing machine."
"These pants are the nicest of quality. The only thing is I got a petite because I am 5’2” but still had to shorten them. Other than that - perfect fit elsewhere."
"I've worn NYDJ Marilyn Straight Jeans in a petite for many years. Recently I have been very frustrated by the fact that the inseam is now 30" rather than 28" which it was previously. As a result, it is necessary for me to pay an additional amount ($18) to have them shortened. I purchased this pair of jeans at a very good price so I wasn't too upset about having to have them shortened. Otherwise, I am very pleased with the fit. However, the increase of 2" in the inseam leaves me less likely to purchase this brand. PLEASE go back to a 28" inseam for this particular style."
"Love these jeans and this was a great buy!"
The Marilyn Straight has a slightly higher rise and a clean straight leg that elongates the silhouette. The Petite version isn't just a shortened Missy jean — the rise, leg opening, and proportions are re-graded specifically for a shorter torso and leg so the waistband, pockets, and hem all sit where they should on a smaller frame. Our signature Lift Tuck® Technology panel is built into the waistband and seat to smooth and support. If you're between sizes, size down for a more fitted look through the hip.
Lift Tuck® is NYDJ's proprietary inner construction — a hidden shaping panel sewn into the waistband and seat that lifts, tucks, and smooths the tummy and rear without the bulk of external shapewear. It's built into the jean itself, so there's nothing extra to wear underneath.
The Petite Marilyn is cut with a shorter inseam (typically for heights 5'4" and under) and proportionally adjusted rise and leg opening — not just a hemmed-up Missy jean. This means the pockets, knee break, and taper all fall in the right place rather than being pushed out of proportion by shortening alone.
Yes — the straight leg and clean dark washes dress up easily with a blazer or heels, while lighter or distressed washes lean casual with sneakers or flats.
Machine wash cold, inside out, with like colors. Avoid high heat in the dryer — tumble low or hang dry — since excess heat breaks down the elastane fibers and reduces stretch recovery over time. Skip fabric softener, which coats the fibers and dulls stretch performance.
Yes. The Marilyn Straight is produced using earth-friendly methods that reduce consumption of water, chemicals, and energy compared to conventional denim processing.
The Marilyn Petite is designed for petite frames (5'4" and under) who want a straight leg that actually fits their proportions, no extra fabric pooling at the ankle, no awkward hemming required. The straight cut skims the hip and thigh rather than clinging, so it flatters curvy, hourglass, and straighter figures alike. Built-in Lift Tuck® Technology lifts and smooths through the front and rear, so whatever your shape, you get a fit that feels tailored rather than generic. It's a versatile, go-to silhouette for petite women who want their jeans to fit their height first, then their curves.
Looks like your cart is empty.
Explore our newest collections or return to your saved favorites.